[linux-dvb] Testing HVR1800

Steven Toth stoth at linuxtv.org
Tue Jan 22 22:21:42 CET 2008


Chaogui Zhang wrote:
> On Jan 22, 2008 1:45 PM, Barry Quiel <quielb at ecst.csuchico.edu> wrote:
>>
>>
>> Chaogui Zhang wrote:
>>> On Jan 22, 2008 5:38 PM, Barry Quiel <quielb at ecst.csuchico.edu> wrote:
>>> [snip]
>>>> So I spoke a bit too soon. For whatever reason it started working in
>>>> Myth, although I still can't get a good cat /dev/video1.  BUt I can't
>>>> change the channel.  When I try and change the channel Mythfrontend
>>>> reports an error and the exits back to the menu.  When I go back into
>>>> livetv it is on the same original channel and there is no audio.  If I
>>>> exit out and go back in I get audio back, but still can;t change the
>>>> channel.
>>>>
>>> Although I don't have the HVR1800...
>>>
>>> In my experience, it is generally easier to test a new driver if you
>>> use simpler applications such as tvtime, azap/dvbscan. These programs
>>> will tell you pretty quickly whether the device and its driver are
>>> working properly or not. Once you are sure the drivers are working
>>> properly, then move on to your favorite media center or any other
>>> program.
>>>
>>> Trying to test device driver with MythTV sometimes muddles the water
>>> too much and you won't know whether it is a problem with the driver or
>>> the application.
>>>
>> I don't think a cat /dev/video1 can get much simpler.  But in this case
>> I am getting results that would appear to be reversed.  The simpler
>> testing method is giving poor results, while the more complex
>> application is giving better results, although not 100%.
>>
> 
> Is the device properly initialized by the driver when you did "cat
> /dev/video1"? Is it tuned to the right channel/frequency/source input?
> "cat /dev/video1" itself lacks the ability to control the device and
> therefore you won't be able to test the driver's ability to change
> channels, for example, without relying on another application.
> 

The driver needs more work, especially for dealing with channel changes 
(and maybe other ioctls).   cat /dev/video1 works fine for me.

- Steve



More information about the linux-dvb mailing list