[linux-dvb] Patch for DigitalNow TinyTwin remote.
mailing-lists at enginuities.com
Wed Apr 22 09:25:59 CEST 2009
You may recall discussing this a while ago, I've been looking in to the problem
with the DigitalNow TinyTwin remote control and believe I have some idea of what
is going on.
> I don't like to touch other than dvb-modules :o I will not apply this to
> my tree / pull-request until whole repeating issue is clear. Why it
> comes and why it does not occur every machine.
I tried a number of things which made no difference until I tried to use the
device with uhci_hcd rather than ehci_hcd. With uhci_hcd there was a 0.27s delay
between key press and release rather than 17.5s with ehci_hcd.
I posted a question on linux-usb (which can be found here:
http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.usb.general/16749) to work out why this
difference was occurring. Alan kindly pointed out that there is probably some
buggy firmware as the device appears to set bInterval for the endpoint
descriptor to 16 regardless of bus speed. This means using uchi_hcd it should be
polled at 16ms and using ehci_hcd it should be polled at 4096ms (however
ehci_hcd clips this to 1024ms).
It seems that the latest firmware version 4.95.0 has a strange 17x delay in it
(16ms x 17 = 272ms or ~0.27s and 1024ms x 17 = 17408ms or ~17.5s). I've found
that Windows should have a polling interval of 32 uframes or 4ms for a high
speed device with 6 <= bInterval <= 255. With a 17x delay this becomes 68ms
which is still small enough to not be a problem.
I've also noticed that there are spurious presses (not reported as events,
spurious interrupt transfers) seen in both Windows and Linux with the 4.95.0
Using the older firmware (4.65.0, 4.71.0 and 4.73.0) all seem to behave better
(not perfectly, but better). They still have a buggy bInterval value where the
full speed value is used for high speed as well (which is masked under Windows)
however this can be worked around in hid-quirks.c.
So, I guess my questions are, is there a revised firmware fixing any of this? Is
there any information about the device firmware to possibly work out what the
firmware is doing and fix it? Is it possible to get information from the
manufacturer? Is there a contact address I could get in contact with to find
Thanks in advance,
More information about the linux-dvb