Mailing List archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[vdr] Re: [PATCH] vdr.1, vdr.5 and UTF-8



Darren Salt wrote:
I demand that Klaus Schmidinger may or may not have written...


Darren Salt wrote:

Even if vdr doesn't get along with UTF-8 locales, there's no reason why
the man pages shouldn't be properly displayable in them. The attached
patch fixes this by escaping hyphens in option names and replacing
non-ASCII characters with equivalent macros.

[ ...manpage_locale_independent.patch...]

Just wondering: is there a particular reason why you left out these:

--- vdr.1       2004/06/13 14:48:03     1.11
+++ vdr.1       2004/12/18 12:26:25
@@ -12,15 +12,15 @@
 [ ... ]
-implements a complete digital Set-Top-Box and Video Recorder.
-It can work with signals received from satellites (DVB-S) as
-well as cable (DVB-C) and terrestrial (DVB-T) signals.
+implements a complete digital Set\-Top\-Box and Video Recorder.
+It can work with signals received from satellites (DVB\-S) as
+well as cable (DVB\-C) and terrestrial (DVB\-T) signals.

Yes. It's only those which really must be literal '-'s which need to be
escaped. (BTW, "set-top box" is correct.)


@@ -127,10 +127,10 @@
.TP
.B 1
An error has been detected which requires the DVB driver and \fBvdr\fR
-to be re-loaded.
+to be re\-loaded.

*That* hyphen should be removed.

[snip]


I guess a simple "change all '-' to '\-'" should be ok, shouldn't it?

No. Normal practice is to use '\-' only where ASCII '-' is required and '-'
where a hyphen is required. (I'm not sure what to do where a minus sign is
required, though: Unicode uses code point 0x2012 for this. Presumably
there's a *roff macro for it.)
To be honest, I find it a little confusing having to distinguish between
normal '-', "hyphen" and "minus" - they're all the same to me.

So, does it hurt if _all_ '-' are escaped? And I mean, does it _really_ hurt?
If not, I'll just escape _all_ '-' characters.

Klaus




Home | Main Index | Thread Index