[linux-dvb] [RFC] Hybrid tuner refactoring, phase 1

Michael Krufky mkrufky at linuxtv.org
Tue Aug 28 22:25:50 CEST 2007


Mauro Carvalho Chehab wrote:
> Hi Michael,
>
> Em Seg, 2007-08-27 às 10:02 -0300, Mauro Carvalho Chehab escreveu:
>   
>> I should review the source code later today.
>>     
>
> Ok. Almost everything looked fine to my eyes. 
>
> I have just one comment, about the changesets that added the
> MODULE_DESCRIPTION and MODULE_LICENSE macros, like on this changeset:
> http://linuxtv.org/hg/~mkrufky/tuner-refactor-phase-1/rev/ff52de4a4da1
>
> This is required at the moment those files will be converted to modules.
> However, as, currently, they are still part of tuner, you shouldn't add
> those lines.
>   
Actually, the driver is split into separate modules as of the changeset 
entitled, "tuner: alter build to produce separate modules"

I could have made those MODULE_DESCRIPTION and MODULE_LICENSE changes 
later on, but it has the same outcome, either way.
> On a future changeset where those drivers will be splat, you should also
> add MODULE_AUTHOR macro.
>   
Will add this right now.
> So, I have some comments about that future patch:
>
> For tea5767 and tea5761, please add:
> MODULE_AUTHOR("Mauro Carvalho Chehab <mchehab at infradead.org>")
>   
OK.
> For tuner-simple, mt20xx and tda8290, I did some research. Those files
> started when Gerd split tuner into smaller drivers, removing tuner.c
> file, at -hg changeset 1578:
> http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/c9083c80e2f0/linux/drivers/media/video/mt20xx.c
>
> Unfortunately, -hg migration didn't preserved the full history (the
> tuner.c removal changeset is not there). However, we can see the other
> side of the history at CVS:
>
> http://linuxtv.org/cgi-bin/viewcvs.cgi/video4linux/Attic/tuner.c?root=v4l&view=markup
>
> The original module author for tuner.c is marked there as:
>
> MODULE_AUTHOR("Ralph Metzler, Gerd Knorr, Gunther Mayer");
>
> This authorship line were preserved at tuner-core.c.
>
> The splitting work, however, were done by Gerd.
>
> So, IANAL, but, to respect GPL, I can see some ways:
>
> a) Preserve the original tuner.c author at the splat drivers;
>
> b) Add just "Gerd Knorr" to the splat drivers, and adding a comment, at
> the header, stating that mt20xx and tuner-simple are splat drivers
> originated from tuner.c, originally written by Ralph Metzler, Gerd
> Knorr, Gunther Mayer.
>
> c) Ask the authors for their wishes (as both Gerd and Ralph are likely
> subscribed at the ML, probably they'll let us know if they opt for an
> specific way. I'm not sure if Gunther is subscribed).
>
> For tda8290, maybe Hartmut should also be added, since he reworked some
> major parts of the driver logic:
>
> http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/399222ddb2d9
OK -- I have taken care of the above, and pushed the changesets into my 
tree, along with the warning of obsolete i2c address usage.

I will issue a pull request tomorrow.

Thanks for your review and testing.

Regards,

Mike




More information about the linux-dvb mailing list